AmpedTraining Blog

Cognitive Gymnastics: Why The Stupid Never Ends

Last week, or whenever that last T-Mag debacle was going on, I mentioned something called the Dunning-Kruger effect a few times. I had originally planned to write up a short research review on this beforehand, but the debacle was just to timely to ignore it.

In any case, this phenomenon is an interesting example of a cognitive bias – that is, a thought process which blinds us or distracts us from objective reality. The Dunning-Kruger effect is what you see when someone incompetent or unqualified judges his/her ability as being far higher than it actually is. In comparison, people that are competent tend to much more conservative and underestimate their own ability.

It really is just a formalization of all the old adages about being smart enough to realize how little you know; people really are too stupid to know they’re stupid. I think a lot of readers thought I was just making it up, but Dunning and Kruger have actually had several papers published on the subject. This is a very real thing, and it has some very interesting implications.

Continue »

Utilitarianism and Exercise: Analyzing “It Works For Me”

I’ve been reading a lot of cognitive science and neuroscience related stuff lately, and it’s had me on a kick with updates that seemingly have very little to do with strength training and exercise.

Well, it does, just indirectly; mainly I’m doing what I do best, which is targeting the flawed thinking and decision-making that most people rely on. Which conveniently manifests itself in fitness-related circles.

A recent debate (argument) on a forum got me thinking about how people look at their own thoughts and behaviors. Namely, people really aren’t thinking about how they think. That may sound like a dog chasing its own tail, but there’s something to be said for self-reflection as it applies to problem-solving.

Since program design and dietary strategies boil down to decision-making and problem-solving activities, this tends to hit home in a lot of ways. Read onwards.

Continue »